Performative Healing, Bypass, and the Illusion of Transformation
How healing culture sells change while avoiding the work
✨ All of my writing is now free to read. I write because I love it, and I believe that wisdom should be accessible, not hidden behind a paywall. Still, creating thoughtful, high-quality content takes a lot of love, time, and the occasional late-night existential spiral. In the spirit of sacred reciprocity, if something here resonates, consider becoming a paid subscriber or buying me a coffee as a one-time offering to support my work.
At the very least, if you find this post valuable, please comment, restack, or share it with someone who might need it.
Healing, at its core, is a deeply personal and relational process. Yet in today’s culture, it has been increasingly co-opted as an identity, a personal brand, and a status symbol. The journey inward, once marked by humility and quiet transformation, has been repackaged for public consumption. This shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone as it’s precisely what modern culture gravitates towards: cold plunges, 4 AM morning routines, body hacks, optimization, wearable tracking devices, quick fixes, and quite frequently, materialism—worldly and spiritual.
Healing culture is nothing more than the spiritual extension of a deeply disconnected and materialistic society.
This phenomenon is particularly visible in the rise of the 'healer' persona. Platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube are flooded with individuals showcasing their 'healing journeys' as a form of content strategy. Language, aesthetics, and curated vulnerability become tools to establish spiritual authority, even when the depth of integration is shallow.
Branding plays a central role. The visual cues are familiar: hand over their heart, a voice perfect for an NPR segment, earth-tone palettes, flat-brimmed hats, sacred geometry, photoshoots in nature, and captions filled with buzzwords like 'embodiment,' 'sovereignty,' and 'sacred space.' While these elements are not inherently problematic, their overuse often signals a performance rather than a lived experience.
Language becomes another layer of this performance. Phrases like 'holding space,' 'doing the work,' and 'aligned in my truth' are deployed liberally, sometimes without a clear understanding of their origins or meanings. This linguistic mimicry creates the illusion of depth, allowing individuals to position themselves as guides, mentors, or facilitators without the necessary inner work or training. One of the biggest challenges in differentiating between real healing and healing culture is that the language is often identical, but the embodiment of that language is entirely different.
In many cases, these individuals are not doing so consciously or with the intention of harm. They simply haven’t done enough of their own work to realize the difference between actual healing and playing the role of healer on TV.
The commodification of healing identity is further fueled by the influencer economy. Visibility is monetized. The more followers, likes, and shares an individual garners, the more their perceived authority grows—regardless of their actual level of embodiment or expertise. This dynamic incentivizes the performance of healing over the practice of it.
But the consequences of this trend are not just superficial. When healing becomes an identity to be performed, it often leads to energetic incongruence. Facilitators may unconsciously project their unhealed parts and energy onto clients. Seekers may feel pressured to adopt the aesthetics and language of healing culture to 'prove' their progress. This creates environments where appearance is prioritized over substance, and true vulnerability is replaced by curated performance.
The rise of healing-as-identity also perpetuates gatekeeping and exclusivity. Those who do not conform to the visual and linguistic codes of the culture may feel alienated or invalidated in their own healing journeys. Conversely, those who excel at the performance can wield unearned influence, shaping narratives and guiding others without the requisite depth of experience.
This is not a condemnation of individuals. Many who participate in these dynamics are sincere seekers, doing their best within a flawed system and often lost in their illusion. The issue lies in the larger cultural forces that reward optics over embodiment, branding over depth, and visibility over integrity.
To navigate this landscape, discernment is essential. Seekers must learn to look beyond the surface—beyond the curated images and eloquent posts—to sense the energetic integrity of those they choose to learn from. Facilitators must engage in continuous self-inquiry (ideally with the support of a teacher, mentor, maestro, supervisor, or peer group), ensuring that their offerings emerge from embodied wisdom rather than unexamined ego.
Recognizing Spiritual, Psychedelic, and Philanthropic Bypass
Bypass is one of the most pervasive and insidious distortions within healing culture. It masquerades as progress, masking unresolved wounds beneath layers of spiritual jargon and performative gestures. While the term 'spiritual bypass'—coined by John Welwood—originally referred to avoiding emotional wounds through spiritual practices, its application has broadened. Today, bypass manifests not only in personal spiritual journeys but also in psychedelic spaces and even philanthropic efforts.
Spiritual bypass often begins with good intentions. Individuals seek to transcend suffering, cultivate higher states of consciousness, or embody spiritual ideals. Yet, without addressing the root causes of their pain—trauma, shadow material, nervous system dysregulation—these pursuits become a means of avoidance. Practices like microdosing, tapping, meditation, or energy healing are used not as tools for deep work, but as temporary agents to bypass and shield against discomfort.
In psychedelic spaces, bypass can take on an even more complex form. Psychedelics, by their nature, dissolve boundaries and reveal profound insights. However, without proper integration, these experiences can become another escape route. People may chase peak states and fantastic visions, mistaking temporary dissolution of ego for genuine transformation. They may adopt the language of expanded consciousness (e.g., “we’re all one” and “there is only love”) while avoiding the grounded, relational work of healing.
A sure-fire way to spot bypass is noticing how someone’s words differ from their actions. Spend enough time with a “We’re all one!” human and watch how quickly the one becomes two when they get cut off in traffic or things don’t go as planned.
Philanthropic bypass adds another layer. Here, individuals or organizations give money, resources, or services—not from a place of relational repair or genuine care, but from guilt, shame, or the desire to manage public perception. The energetic frequency of these actions carries subtle distortions. While material outcomes may seem beneficial, the underlying motivations can perpetuate dynamics of disempowerment and dependency.
For recipients, this creates a complex dynamic. Assistance received through philanthropic bypass often comes with invisible strings. There’s a felt sense of superiority, obligation, or subtle control. The energy of 'helping' can inadvertently reinforce hierarchies, disempower local solutions, and maintain the giver’s image of benevolence.
Recognizing these patterns requires deep self-inquiry. For givers, the question becomes: Am I offering this from a place of genuine relational care, or to soothe my own discomfort (or tax burden)? For receivers, the question might be: Does this support feel empowering, or does it subtly diminish my agency?
In all cases, bypass thrives in spaces where depth is sacrificed for optics. It seduces with promises of quick fixes, elevated status, or moral superiority. But its impact is felt in the subtle incongruence between words and energy, appearance and embodiment.
Once again, cultivating discernment is essential. This involves tuning into the somatic cues that reveal energetic misalignments—gut feelings, nervous system responses, and relational dynamics. It also requires slowing down, creating space for reflection, and seeking out relationships rooted in mutual respect, honesty, and accountability.
By recognizing and naming bypass in its various forms, we reclaim the possibility of authentic healing. We shift from performance to presence, from optics to embodiment, from guilt-driven action to genuine relational repair.
Impact Dissonance and Energetic Mismatch
Impact dissonance (a term I think I invented) is a subtle yet profound phenomenon: it’s what happens when external good is done from a place of internal distortion. On the surface, the action appears beneficial—helping, healing, giving—but beneath it runs an energetic current of unresolved guilt, shame, scarcity, or ego. This mismatch between intention and energetic signature creates dissonance, often felt but rarely named.
Consider the metaphor of serving food made with spoiled ingredients. The presentation is flawless: a beautifully plated dish, garnished and glowing under perfect lighting. To the untrained eye, it’s nourishing, even luxurious. But beneath the surface, the ingredients are compromised. Consuming it might fill the belly, but it leaves the body ill at ease. This is impact dissonance in action.
In healing spaces, this looks like facilitators holding ceremonies while bypassing their own shadows. It looks like influencers sharing 'vulnerable' posts to maintain engagement metrics (honestly, this is the reason I made all my Substack articles free) rather than to foster genuine connection. It looks like philanthropists donating large sums to causes while perpetuating the very systems of exploitation that created the need for charity in the first place.
For recipients, impact dissonance is felt as a subtle energetic mismatch. Something is off, though it may be difficult to articulate. The words sound right. The gestures appear generous. But the body and soul sense the incongruence. Recipients may feel subtly disempowered, obligated, or even manipulated.
This isn’t about perfection. All humans carry wounds, and no action is ever entirely 'pure.' But when the dominant motivation stems from unexamined egoic drives—be it guilt, image management, or the need for control—the energetic distortion outweighs the material good.
For practitioners and leaders, mitigating impact dissonance requires rigorous self-inquiry and asking questions like:
Why am I offering this service or support?
Is my giving tied to a need to be seen, validated, or forgiven?
Am I projecting my unhealed parts onto those I aim to help?
For seekers, discerning impact dissonance involves attuning to the body’s subtle responses:
Does this offering feel nourishing, or does it come with invisible strings?
Do I feel empowered after receiving, or subtly diminished?
Is there a felt sense of reciprocity, or a power imbalance?
Cultivating this discernment is both an individual and collective responsibility. It requires slowing down, listening deeply, and developing the capacity to sense energetic nuance.
Discernment Over Desperation
In a culture saturated with healing content, discerning genuine transformation from performance is no small feat. For seekers and facilitators alike, the temptation to bypass—whether consciously or unconsciously—is amplified by systems that reward optics over substance. This makes discernment not just a helpful skill but a necessary practice for energetic hygiene and self-responsibility.
Discernment begins with slowing down. Desperation thrives in urgency. When we are desperate—for healing, for belonging, for validation—we are more susceptible to superficial solutions. Slowing down disrupts this dynamic, giving us space to attune to our inner knowing and sense subtle energetic cues.
For seekers, discernment involves both internal reflection and external observation. Internally, it means cultivating self-awareness around our motivations. Are we seeking healing from a place of curiosity and commitment, or from a desire to fix, escape, or be seen? Externally, it means paying attention to how a facilitator, space, or community feels—not just how it looks or sounds.
Practical tools for discernment include:
Trust Your Intuition: For newcomers to the path, this may feel like a challenge, but when you sense a knot in your stomach or the gentle nudge of your deeper knowing, this is a good time to pause or walk away altogether.
Body-Based Sensing: Notice your somatic responses when engaging with a potential teacher, offering, or space. Do you feel expansive, grounded, and curious? Or do you feel constricted, anxious, or subtly obligated?
Pause Before Commitment: Resist the pull of urgency. Take time to reflect before enrolling in a program, attending a ceremony, or following a new guide. Desperation clouds discernment.
Evaluate Track Records: Look beyond marketing. How long has this person been doing the work? What do their peers and community members say? Is there evidence of ongoing learning, supervision, and accountability?
Seek Referrals: Personal recommendations from trusted sources often carry more weight than polished testimonials and beautiful Instagram posts.
Inquire About Integration: Genuine facilitators prioritize integration as much as peak experiences. Ask how they support the aftercare and long-term embodiment of the work.
For facilitators, discernment involves a parallel process of self-responsibility. It’s essential to continuously assess whether offerings are emerging from embodied experience or from unexamined egoic drives or unmet emotional needs. Apprenticeship, regular supervision, peer feedback, and personal shadow work are non-negotiables for maintaining energetic integrity.
Energetic hygiene practices for facilitators might include:
Daily self-regulation rituals to maintain clarity and presence.
Regular check-ins with teachers, mentors, or supervisors.
Transparent communication about personal limits and ongoing areas of growth.
Commitment to lineage-informed practices and ethical boundaries.
Discernment over desperation is an act of relational care. It protects both seekers and facilitators from entangling in bypass dynamics and fosters environments where genuine healing can occur.
Ultimately, discernment is not about judgment, cynicism, or constant suspicion. It’s about cultivating the ability to feel, sense, and respond to energetic realities with clarity and compassion.
The Gentle Initiation
In my early years of 12-Step work, my sponsor often reminded me that “The goal of this work is to make our outsides look like our insides.” While simple in theory, it’s much more difficult in practice. Here are a few common ways we begin to recognize we’re out of alignment.
One of the most common ways we step into awareness around our bypass is realizing how fragmented our life feels. Frequently, individuals will rely on secrecy (sometimes coded as confidentiality) between different aspects of their lives. How they present in one group may be radically different than how they show up in another.
Another Universal tap on the shoulder is when an individual realizes that the stories they’re telling themselves about their life are different than the feedback they receive from their community. An inner monologue that says, “I’ve got it all together,” met with a consistent, “You’re dropping the ball,” may be just enough to break down an unconscious barrier of internal deception.
Finally, a more drastic signal that things are out of alignment is frequent geographic changes. Many people deeply entrenched in delusion will frequently move to a new location, change their friend group or community, or escape from reality altogether. In the psychedelic world, this might look like moving to the jungle to become a shaman or going off the grid to attain enlightenment. In reality, we can never become enlightened on the mountaintop; we must learn to deal with the responsibilities and triggers of daily life
Waking up to the reality of bypass and impact dissonance can be disorienting. For many, it feels like the ground shifts beneath their feet—a painful realization that the healing culture they trusted is not what it seemed. But this moment of awakening is not a failure. It is the first, crucial step into deeper, slower, and more authentic healing work.
The path forward requires grace.
Grace for ourselves, as we reckon with the ways we have participated in performative healing, whether consciously or not. Grace for others, who may still be entangled in the illusions of healing culture, unaware of the energetic ripples their actions create.
The gentle initiation is not about blame or shame. It is an invitation to slow down, to rest, and to approach healing with renewed humility. It acknowledges that true transformation cannot be rushed, branded, or optimized. It unfolds in relationship—with self, with others, with spirit, and with the earth.
This initiation asks us to practice what I call the “4 Rs”:
Rest: To step back from the constant drive to 'do the work' and instead allow space for integration.
Reflect: To engage in honest self-inquiry about our motivations, actions, and energetic alignments.
Recommit: To return to the roots of healing as a sacred, relational, and embodied practice.
Reconnect: To seek out communities, teachers, and practices that prioritize depth over visibility.
As leaders, healers, and humans, we must realize that when we have found ourselves in a state of illusion, we must step back and pause. We must understand that any healing we do from this place may only spread more confusion and harm. We must realize that any true repair requires a change in our behavior.
Once we have awareness that our thinking, words, or actions are causing rupture, if we do not go about the very intentional process of transformation—that is, positive change designed to decrease suffering for ourselves and others—we are now out of integrity. For those on the path of healing, this is a very precarious road to hoe. As the proverb states, “we reap what we sow,” and the consequences of our actions only get worse as our consciousness increases, both in this lifetime and future lifetimes.
For facilitators, this might mean taking time away from public teaching or ceremony to focus on personal shadow work. For seekers, it could involve stepping back from social media narratives and tuning into the quieter wisdom of their own bodies and hearts. In both cases, the work needs to be done in the privacy of your own heart rather than as a public spectacle designed for engagement and conversion.
The gentle initiation is a threshold. Crossing it requires courage—not the courage to perform, but the courage to be with what is real, messy, and unfinished.
It is through this humility that we reclaim the sacredness of healing. We move from performance to presence. From illusion to embodiment. From bypass to belonging.
This is not a linear process. There will be moments of forgetting, of slipping back into old patterns. However, with each cycle of reflection and recommitment, the foundation of our healing becomes deeper.
But the best part of forgetting is that we get to remember.
In the final article in this series, I am going to propose a bold offering: that healing must become the foundation for leadership. We’ll examine how unhealed individuals perpetuate harm through positions of power and how a new ethic of leadership—rooted in emotional maturity, relational accountability, and spiritual integrity—can transform not only our personal lives but the collective systems we inhabit.
Because true healing is not the end of the journey—it is the beginning of true service.
